Is gastric bypass surgery a miracle cure for the U.S. obesity
By: Marci A. Landsmann
Article courtesy Chapman Medical Center
Vol. 12 Issue 5 • Page 57, Issue Date: May 01, 2003
We've all seen singer Carnie Wilson on TV, touting the benefits of
surgery. She is transformed before our eyes from a size 28 to a size 6.
Such dramatic images tantalize, forcing us to ask a question: Is
gastric bypass surgery the answer to the growing obesity epidemic, or
is it a miracle cure that's just too good to be true?
As obesity rises in this country, more people regularly wage war
the bulge. Diets succeed only to fail months later. Waistlines grow. It
was a routine 54-year-old Barbara Thompson knew by heart. A college
librarian and author of Weight Loss Surgery: Finding the Thin
Person Hiding Inside of You, Thompson is 5 feet and 7 inches and
weighed 264 pounds.
She recalls the day her physician detailed her probable success of
loss. If she went on a traditional diet, she could expect to lose
nearly 5 percent of her body weight—about 13 pounds. With the help of
diet drugs, she could lose 10 percent of her body weight, or about 26
pounds. With surgery, the physician told her, she could lose between 50
percent and 80 percent of her body weight. She knew at that moment what
it would take to beat her weight problem.
"I was so devastated," she says when she realized that surgery was
way to control her weight. After one final good faith effort in dieting
and yet another failure, Thompson decided to undergo surgery.
Many people who are morbidly obese (characterized by a BMI of 40
roughly 100 pounds overweight) have a history of similar yo-yo diet
attempts. Countless studies show that diet regimens fail to provide
long-term weight control in severely obese patients. One
study even proved the majority of patients regain the weight they lose
in five years' time.
Patients who are morbidly obese have a lot of incentive for wanting
those pounds—and it's not just for self-image. Obesity takes a toll on
the body, exposing it to a host of health problems, including diabetes,
digestive tract disease, cardiopulmonary problems and hyperlipidemia,
to name a few. These health problems shorten life spans and compromise
quality of life.
With these cold facts in front of her, Thompson underwent one of the
popular weight loss surgeries (as did Carnie Wilson), called Roux-en-Y
gastric bypass (RGB). The RGB creates a small, stapled pouch in the
stomach, making it the size of an egg. A surgeon attaches a part of the
small intestine directly to the stomach pouch, effectively bypassing
the lower stomach and the upper portions of the intestine. The surgery,
which on average takes about two hours, restricts food intake and the
amount of calories and nutrients the body absorbs, helping patients
Successful surgeries often bring amazing results. A 400-pound person
to lose 100 to 150 pounds in the first nine months. And
patients don't have to worry about the seesaw effect that once came
with dieting. On average, patients lose 50 percent to 60 percent of
their excess body weight even 10 to 14 years after surgery.
In addition, patients with obesity can climb out of life-threatening
health categories. Blood sugar levels come back to normal, orthopedic
pain often disappears, and cholesterol levels improve.
But getting a new lease on life doesn't come without costs.
There is a significant risk when undergoing this surgery, says Dirk
Rodriguez, MD, a board-certified surgeon who specializes in
laparoscopic RGB in Dallas. One out of every 200 patients dies. Experts
attribute this mortality rate to the high-risk patient population;
often these patients are de-conditioned and present with several
complicating factors. Therefore, any surgery is risky.
One in four people will experience a complication from surgery, says
Rodriguez, noting that these statistics could translate into something
minor or deadly. One of the most dreaded repercussions of surgery is a
gastric leak (occurring about 2 percent of the time, in
which the pouch isn't completely sealed. Having gastric fluid leak into
the stomach can cause a deadly infection.
Other complications exist as well. One out of four patients will
hernias or wound infections. Now, however, laparoscopic
surgery can reduce these complications. But it's complex.
"Laparoscopic gastric bypass surgery is probably the most difficult
perform," says Dr. Rodriguez, largely because a surgeon needs to cut
across three tightly nestled intestinal units: the stomach, small bowel
and the colon. Navigating this area with a laparoscope takes a trained
eye and a lot of patience. To truly master the technique, surgeons may
need to perform as many as 100 procedures, says Dr. Rodriguez.
After the surgery, patients must conform to a new lifestyle,
frequent medical follow-up. Right after surgery, patients will be on a
liquid diet for two weeks, with solid food being introduced gradually.
Because patients have a smaller stomach, they will never be able to
"cheat" on diets. If they eat an ice cream dessert, they could
experience a symptom called "dumping," which temporarily produces
nausea, vomiting, dizziness and sweating. Therefore, patients need to
painstakingly monitor what they eat. (They generally will feel full
after eating a meal comparable to half a sandwich and a small salad.)
The surgery also causes nutritional deficits because it bypasses
the stomach and intestine that absorb nutrients from food. Patients
will need to take iron, calcium and B-12 supplements for the rest of
In addition, they will need to exercise to reap the full effects of
"Increasing muscle mass is the most effective thing patients can to
do to lose
weight," says Milton Owens, MD, medical director for the Coastal Center
for Obesity, Orange, Calif. This surgeon, who has performed more than
1,500 gastric bypasses, recommends starting with the upper body, where
there is the most chance for muscle gain.
Dr. Owens refers his patients to a physical therapist before and
surgery. This person often teaches them about gradually incorporating
exercise into their lives.
Michael Dionne, PT, owner of Choice Physical Therapy in Gainesville,
that physical therapists may actually lose their patient base because
the weight loss surgery often heals orthopedic problems and existing
health conditions. Dionne, who nationally educates health care
providers about the intricacies of treating bariatric populations, sees
a place for physical therapists in caring for these patients
post-operatively. Ideally, he sees many hospitals incorporating these
patients into their cardiac III rehab programs.
He also notes the importance of being aware of the delicate nature
with obesity. Any period of inactivity can cause unexpected muscle
weakness—and falls. Patients of size, therefore, must be treated with
Even with the risks of the surgery, an estimated 90,000 people will
knife or laparoscope to shed their pounds nationwide this year.
This is double the amount of people who underwent surgery in 2002.
Most surgeons believe the procedure should be reserved for people
weight is out of control. Many people, faced with an onslaught of other
health problems, accept the risks.
"There's a lot of prejudice against any kind of surgery for these
patients, but you are trading one risk for another," says Dr. Owens,
alluding to numerous health problems obese patients often experience.
The NIH published guidelines to set parameters for the patient
emphasizing the importance of screening. According to the
guidelines, patients must have a BMI of 40 and must have tried and
failed at dieting for at least a year. Surgeons also can consider
patients with a BMI of 35, if these patients have other health risks,
such as life-threatening cardiopulmonary problems, joint disease and
severe diabetes. The NIH also recommends patients undergo mental health
The surgery, which costs between $20,000 and $25,000, is sometimes
by insurance—provided the person meets the NIH guidelines.
But many insurance companies still systematically deny the surgery for
morbidly obese patients, says Dr. Owens.
No matter who pays, the field continues to expand. Revenue from this
surgery was projected to reach $1.8 billion nationwide last year alone.
That number was expected to increase an additional 60 percent to 70
percent this year.
Nearly 800 surgeons perform gastric bypass surgery, according to the
Society of Bariatric Surgery, a medical organization that educates and
researches information about bariatric surgery. These surgeons can
hardly meet the demand as waiting lists grow. Just ask Dr. Owens, who
started doing this surgery in 1987.
"When I got into this surgery, my colleagues looked at me as if I
obstetrician performing abortions," he recalls. "But now, many of my
colleagues are asking me what they should do to open up their offices."
For Thompson, who wears a size 8 and lost 125 pounds, it's not about
monetary cost. It's about reaching up for a book at work without
flinching in pain. It's about enjoying 18 holes of golf instead of
four. She sees fewer barriers and horizons of possibility.
"People need to understand it's a health issue," she says. "If your
at beating a health problem is having surgery, then absolutely have
that surgery. This is not about cosmetics. It's about life."
For a list of references, go to www.ADVANCE.forDR.com
and click on the references tool bar.
Marci A. Landsmann is associate editor.
2900 Horizon Drive, King of Prussia, PA 19406 • 800-355-5627
Publishers of ADVANCE Newsmagazines